I get these occasionally, “we owe money to China” or “what
if China sells off all of our bonds”.
I think the first part is much more complicated than simply
“we owe money to China” and can explained walking through why China owes
Treasuries:
- We buy goods from China ABC Co.
- Before we buy we need to covert dollars to Yuan (CNY), so we sell USD and buy Yuan for the transaction
- Ultimately the above transaction arrives on the currency market and puts downward pressure on USD
- We are net importers of Chinese goods; as a result there should be more supply of USD relative to CNY, lowering the value of USD/CNY.
- Except there is no downward pressure because China’s Central Bank intervenes and buys those dollars
- So now what does their Central Bank do now? They obviously want USD or wouldn’t have purchased it, so they invest in the safest USD asset around – Treasuries.
That is probably an oversimplification, but what I am
getting at is that we “owe” China money due to trade. Would they sell our bonds? I don’t know, maybe. So what?
- If they are selling, someone is buying. Given where interest rates are there is plenty of demand.
- This would put downward pressure on USD, making our exports more competitive.
- Given their large holdings of Treasuries, why would China have a “fire sale”? It would crush exports to their largest (or second largest) customer and harm their own central bank balance sheet.
- Note #1 assumes this is done more orderly than just dumping all $1.5t or so Treasuries on the market.
Again, this is an oversimplification and I am certainly
missing a few steps. Further, I will
admit this is above my pay grade. I am
just trying to outline that it is much more complicated than “we owe China” and
if they do sell our bonds it could yield positive benefits to our exports.